Creamy Crab Soup
I got this recipe from a dear friend in the 1990’s, and I had probably not made it in 20 years. It is so good though, and so very easy! Chop everything, then dump in a big soup pot and you have delicious creamy crab soup in no time!
Ingredients
Instructions
  1. Original Recipe Instructions: Combine and heat all ingredients together, stirring constantly.
  2. This soup is better if made the day before
  3. Stacy’s Directions: I like to saute the green onions in the butter before adding the other ingredients. I was taking this to a party, so I made it on the stovetop in a big Dutch oven and then transferred to my crockpot to transport and stay warm. I made it a few hours ahead of time, to give the flavors time to meld.
Recipe Notes

Stacy’s Notes:

  • I made this a lot in the 90’s until Tim deemed it “girlie soup” and then I stopped making it!  Made it in February 2020 for a “Souper Bowl” party and it turned out really well.
  • Per my tastes, I use 2 cans of cream of mushroom and 1 can of cream of chicken (since I’m not a celery fan).
  • I used half and half, and did pour the half and half in the 3 soup cans and sloshed them around to get everything out. I ended up adding the rest of the quart (2 pints) of half and half, which made it a bit thinner, but it was still good, more a soup than a chowder.
  • When I received this recipe from a dear friend, it said to use 2 cans of “crab claw meat”. I couldn’t find those, so I bought Bumblebee brand canned crabmeat. I opened the cans and expected to have to pick out cartilage and bones, but it was very clean and ready to use.
  • I normally add 1 package (1 lb) of imitation crab meat.  However, when I made this soup and filmed for our Youtube video, I was overzealous and chopped the imitation crab very fine. I wanted there to be bigger pieces of meat, so I ran to the store and purchased a second package of imitation crabmeat, and chopped it much larger. I would do this again. It was much better with two packages of imitation crab versus one package.
  • I don’t keep sherry in the house, so I substituted 2 teaspoons of white wine vinegar for the 2 TABLEspoons of sherry
  • For seasonings, I added salt, white pepper and a few dashes of Old Bay seasoning.